An abstract black icon showing four sharp triangles on a base is surrounded by four circular images with question marks and arrows pointing to it, illustrating different potential interpretations: a gold crown, pine trees, bullets, and pointed rooftops.

Why User Testing Is the Only Reliable Way to Verify Your Design

by Caitlin Snethlage and Laia Tremosa • • 14 min read

220 Shares
Save

You designed a healer character: flowing robes, gentle colors, a staff with a glowing crystal. During your first playtest, three players immediately identify her as the damage dealer. "The staff looks powerful," one explains. This is exactly why you test, to identify the mismatches between your intention and players' perception. You act on the feedback, reduce the staff's size, replace the crystal with a soft green glow, and add a small cross symbol near the grip. By the next session, players instantly recognize her role. Testing gave you the insight you couldn't see on your own.

In this video, Celia Hodent, PhD, Game UX Strategist and Author of the best-selling book The Gamer's Brain, explains why testing is the only reliable way to verify that players perceive your designs as you intended.

Copyright
Transcript

Test Early, Test the Right Things

You already know you need to test. The next step is deciding what to test and when to test it. Here's how to approach it:

  • You can test icons and HUD elements with paper prototypes or digital sketches before anything is polished. At this stage, you're not judging whether they look good. You're checking whether players understand what they mean. Show players the icon and ask what they think it represents. If their answer is different from what you intended, that tells you something useful. The icon may not be communicating clearly enough yet. When that happens, resist the urge to explain the icon to players. Change the icon.

  • You can also test character design. In team-based games, players may need to recognize roles like tank, healer, or DPS quickly. Show players the character design and ask what role they would expect that character to play. If players look at your heavily armored tank and assume he is the damage dealer because his sword is oversized, that's useful feedback. It means the design may be sending the wrong signal and you need to adjust it.

  • Environment design needs its own set of questions. Can players tell tall grass from regular grass and understand that it has a different function, such as hiding? Can they distinguish a door that opens from one that doesn't? Can they identify what's breakable and what gives reliable cover? Can they tell where to go next? Any information your game needs players to read correctly is worth testing before it's baked into a finished build.

  • Sound design follows the same logic. If players interpret your lion growl as a cat meowing, they won't respond the way you expected. Test how players interpret sounds too.

Test With the Right People

Who you test with matters as much as what you test. If you're building an RPG, don't recruit players who primarily play puzzle games. The visual language differs significantly between genres, and your testers need to share the same symbol fluency as your target audience. Also, include players with disabilities to ensure your designs work across the full range of people who'll actually play your game.

This range of perspectives is useful because different players bring different cultural references, gaming histories, and ways of constructing meaning from the same visual information. That variation helps you find out where your design holds and where it breaks.

The Take Away

Testing is essential because you can't perceive your design the way players perceive it. You already know what each icon, character, sound, or environment cue is supposed to mean. Players don'thave that context, and different players may bring different experiences to the same design. Testing helps you check whether there's a mismatch between what you intended and what players perceived, so you can adjust the design while the game is still in development.

References and Where to Learn More

Want more? If you haven't already, sign up for Game UX Design: The Ultimate Guide to learn directly from Celia Hodent, PhD, former Fortnite UX Director, and author of the best-seller The Gamer's Brain.

Read The Gamer's Brain by Celia Hodent.

Watch the How to Design for the Human Mind: Cognitive Science for UX Master Class by Celia Hodent.

Watch the How to Become a Games User Researcher Master Class by Steve Bromley, Games Researcher and Author.

Watch the AI for Game UX: Speed Up Research, Ideas, and Prototypes Master Class by Om Tandon, UX Design Leader at Nordeus (Zynga/Take-Two).

Watch the Level Up Your Career: How to Land a Job in the Game Industry Master Class with Om Tandon, UX Design Leader at Nordeus (Zynga/Take-Two).

Watch the UI Design for Games: Starter Edition Master Class with Stéfano Girardelli, Senior Visual Designer at Wildlife Studios.

Hero image: © Interaction Design Foundation, CC BY-SA 4.0

Learn More in This Course:

Learn Design and AI From the Best

Get one powerful email each week, like 311,220 others.

Next email in:

What You Should Read Next

  • Read full article
    Sustainability Is Not Enough - Article hero image

    Sustainability Is Not Enough

    Sustainable design. Sustainable fashion. Sustainable living. We often hear these terms in marketing campaigns and popular media. But what does sustainability mean and why does pioneer of User Experience Design Don Norman think that sustainability shouldn’t be our goal when we design?In this video, D

    Social shares
    484
    Published
    Read Article
  • Read full article
    Black Friday 2024: Invest in UX Design Education - Article hero image

    Black Friday 2024: Invest in UX Design Education

    “The best investment you can make, is an investment in yourself... The more you learn, the more you'll earn.”—Warren Buffett, Chairman and CEO of Berkshire HathawayHow many items have you added to your Black Friday shopping wishlist? This year, instead of short-term deals on products, why not take a

    Social shares
    563
    Published
    Read Article
  • Read full article
    Why Is AI so Important and How Is It Changing the World? - Article hero image

    Why Is AI so Important and How Is It Changing the World?

    You've heard about AI and all the wonderful (and sometimes scary) possibilities. But unlike sci-fi apocalyptic movies, AI isn't out to destroy humanity. Let's take a look at the challenges and opportunities we face as AI meets design.In this video, Ioana Teleanu, Founder of UX Goodies and former Lea

    Social shares
    486
    Published
    Read Article
  • Read full article
    Who, What, and How: Design Maps Show You the Way for Implementation - Article hero image

    Who, What, and How: Design Maps Show You the Way for Implementation

    For something called a “team project,” it’s amazing how often everyone’s on a different page. Design maps connect the dots. They organize your research, stories of use, and design artifacts into clear, user-centered interfaces that your team can actually build fast. No more “Wait, what did you mean

    Social shares
    401
    Published
    Read Article
  • Read full article
    How Can Designers Adapt to New Technologies? The Future of Technology in Design - Article hero image

    How Can Designers Adapt to New Technologies? The Future of Technology in Design

    The design industry is rapidly evolving with the integration of technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI) and 3D printing. While there may be concerns about job displacement, history has demonstrated that new technologies typically create more job opportunities. Don Norman, author of The Des

    Social shares
    690
    Published
    Read Article
  • Read full article
    Conceptual Models: The Hidden Structure Behind Your Next Great Interface - Article hero image

    Conceptual Models: The Hidden Structure Behind Your Next Great Interface

    Ever wondered why some interfaces feel effortless: like they already know what you’re trying to do, while others leave you guessing? The difference often lies in how well a product’s design matches the way users think. When your interface reflects their mental model, every action feels intuitive, an

    Social shares
    479
    Published
    Read Article
  • Read full article
    Get to Grips with Constraints - Article hero image

    Get to Grips with Constraints

    Got constraints? Perfect. That’s where great design begins. Just as electrical standards define how a toaster safely works without shaping what it does, your software also lives within boundaries that quietly guide its behavior. Functional requirements describe what your system does: the stories of

    Social shares
    475
    Published
    Read Article
  • Read full article
    How Persona Stories Help You Design for Real People - Article hero image

    How Persona Stories Help You Design for Real People

    User stories caught on because they were quick and simple, but speed often came at the cost of real understanding. A “user” in a story is rarely more than a guess, shaped by the assumptions of whoever wrote it. When you shift to persona stories, you ground your work in real research and real people.

    Social shares
    400
    Published
    Read Article
  • Read full article
    Use Cases: The Ideal Bridge Between Requirements and Design? - Article hero image

    Use Cases: The Ideal Bridge Between Requirements and Design?

    Imagine trying to describe everything your product needs to do, without getting lost in technical detail or endless feature lists. That’s the problem Ivar Jacobson set out to solve in the 1980s when he introduced use cases. Instead of worrying about how a system worked internally, he described it fr

    Social shares
    418
    Published
    Read Article
  • Read full article
    What is Good Design? - Article hero image

    What is Good Design?

    Design matters. It enables us to understand, communicate and improve the world around us. When done right, design has the power to improve the everyday lives of users. When done wrong, design can disrupt and frustrate users. As a designer, you have the power to improve the everyday lives of your use

    Social shares
    670
    Published
    Read Article

Top Articles

Top Topic Definitions

39% of Today's Skills Will Change by 2030

The World Economic Forum expects 39% of today's skills to be transformed or become outdated by 2030.

The good news is that jobs in UX / UI design and AI are among the fastest-growing professions globally.

Build Skills That Keep You Relevant

Privacy Settings

By using this site, you accept our Cookie Policy and Terms of Use.
Customize
Accept all

Be the One Who Inspires

People remember who shares great ideas.

Share on:

Academic Credibility — On Autopilot

Don't waste time googling citation formats. Just copy, paste and look legit in seconds.

Learn Design and AI From the Best

Get one powerful email each week, like 311,220 others.

Next email in: